Beautiful & Elegant

Custom Wedding Cakes

At I Do! Wedding Cakes, we know you've anticipated this moment forever and you want nothing more than to make it magical and unforgettable. So why settle for a cookie-cutter wedding cake?

Shine in the spotlight on your big day with one of our gorgeous wedding cakes that will leave an unforgettable impression. Personalized and custom-made at no added cost, our cakes are available in fondant or buttercream finishes.

My husband and I were just talking about how much we loved our wedding cake 10 years ago! I Do! Wedding Cakes did such a beautiful job!

Natasha G.

Showing 12 of 182


Ready to say I Do?

Our friendly cake experts are here to help you every step of the way. You’ll never feel pressured or overwhelmed with us. Discover why our couples say we're the best in Toronto for wedding cakes.

Wedding Cake FAQs

Expand All
  • To determine the size of cake you’ll need, you’ll need to decide how to serve your cake. Either later in the evening or as the plated dessert.

    Aim for 50-65% of your total guest count when serving at a late-night table. Not everyone will help themselves to a slice of cake. This option allows for minimal waste and you'll save more money.

    Serving the cake as the main dessert requires a serving for each guest. Before settling on this option, you should inquire about your venue's cake-cutting fee. An added cost you might not be aware of.

  • Our wedding cakes are affordably priced and range from $440 for a 2-tier wedding cake to $1685 for a 5-tier wedding cake. For a stress-free shopping experience, we base our prices on the cake size, not the cake design. View our full price list here.

    In the province of Ontario, taxes are not applicable on cakes.

  • Absolutely. Send us an email with your dream cake design and include the size and/or number of servings. We’ll do whatever we can to keep it within our all-inclusive pricing structure or gladly suggest cost-saving alternatives.

  • Yes, we offer the option of false tiers on all of our fondant cake designs.

    False tiers are offered to save in cost when you opt to serve fewer guests (10-30% rather than the suggested 65%)

    Slab cake, which is undecorated and kept in the kitchen, is available for $3.75/serving.

    When false tiers are combined with slab cakes, there are no savings. Quite the opposite. Because false tiers also require decorating, the overall cost will increase due to the addition of slab cake.

    Brand new for 2024, we now offer wedding cake rentals to help couples save even more.

  • Not at all.

    We know that your ideas and vision can change throughout the planning process and will stay flexible throughout the process.

    At your initial consultation, we’ll go over your wedding details and explore your design ideas. There’s no pressure to decide on the spot. Often, couples find it hard to settle on a vision as the wedding details ie. flowers, and decor aren’t usually confirmed until 2-3 months before the big day.

    If a design has not been chosen, a follow-up consultation 1-2 months before the wedding date will be arranged. At the final consultation, we’ll confirm your RSVP numbers and discuss any change in size or design you’d like to make.

  • Cake Tastings are made available by purchasing our beautifully boxed cake-tasting kit.

    Each box is available for $35 and comes with all 14 of our delectable flavours. This is a stand-alone fee not applied to the wedding cake order. For more information, visit our wedding cakes flavours page and discover your favourite today.

wedding cake winter promotion - save $130 until february 9th